Smart House London

Voice assistants are everywhere these days – on your phone, in your home speakers, even in your fridge. They’re like your personal genie, ready to do whatever you ask. Need to make a call? Tell them who, and they’ll dial it up. Want to groove to your favorite tunes? Name the song, and just relax and enjoy!

All these cool features have sparked a big question: which voice assistant reigns supreme? It’s like a never-ending duel between the three most popular assistants Alexa, Siri, and Google Assistant. Choosing between them feels like an impossible task, as each has its own special skills and quirks, and the competition is fierce.

So, to help you make the right choice, we’re stepping in to tell you how these voice assistants compare. In this simple guide, we’ll break down how these digital helpers handle different tasks. Get ready to witness the ultimate showdown: Alexa vs Siri vs Google Assistant. Let’s settle this once and for all!

Alexa vs Google assistant vs Siri: A brief overview

Before we discuss how these voice assistants compares, let’s give you a brief overview first – starting with Alexa, Amazon’s virtual assistant. She made her debut in 2014 alongside Amazon Echo devices.

Alexa is quite capable when it comes to working with your smart home gadgets. You can speak to her naturally, say “Alexa,” and she’s ready to help. She boasts over 100,000 skills, assisting you with tasks like playing your favorite tunes or ordering pizza. And it’s pretty popular in many homes with Amazon having sold more than 500 million Alexa-enabled devices.

Moving on to Siri. Since her introduction in 2011 with the iPhone 4S, Siri has become a staple in all Apple products.

Siri’s known for her wit among all the voice assistants. For instance, if you were to ask her, “Which is the best smartphone?” and she’ll humorously reply, “Wait… there are other phones?” She also seamlessly integrates with iOS and the Apple ecosystem, handling tasks like sending iMessages, making FaceTime calls, or opening apps. All you have to do is ask!

Now, let’s talk about Google Assistant.

Google Assistant burst onto the scene in 2016 and quickly gained popularity. She’s quite adept at understanding natural language commands, thanks to her advanced Natural Language Processing capabilities. In simpler terms, she gets what you’re saying, whether you’re typing or talking. Google Assistant can also interact with third-party apps, and so, can easily estimate your arrival time while driving, for instance. Plus, she’s good at keeping up with the conversation’s context, making it ideal for a friendly chat.

These are just quick glimpses into what these three voice assistants can do. For a more detailed comparison, let’s explore them further across various aspects!

Alexa vs Siri vs Google Assistant: how do they compare

Smart home control

Alexa is really good at managing smart homes. In fact, we can say it is the best assistant for smart home control, and it’s because it was launched earlier than the rest, in 2014. This gave it a big advantage. Since then, Alexa has become compatible with lots of smart devices, from simple ones like light bulbs to more complicated ones like lawnmowers and fridges. In fact, if you want to automate your home, chances are that there is an Alexa option out there.

With Alexa, you just talk to it and it does what you ask. Whether you want it to alter the temperature in your home or change the color of the lights, just ask! It’s also really easy to set up routines with Alexa. These routines make things happen automatically based on the time of day or certain commands you give to Alexa. The best thing is that you can control everything with the Alexa app, which is easy to use and lets you manage your smart home easily.

Google Assistant shares many similarities with Alexa but also introduces its unique advantages. While it can perform many of the same tasks, setting up routines with Google Assistant might require a bit more effort. However, a standout feature of Google Assistant is its ability to understand and execute multiple commands in a single sentence. For instance, you could ask it to turn off lights in two different rooms simultaneously, and it will execute. This capability surpasses that of other assistants, which typically handle one command at a time.

Siri, on the other hand, operates within the Apple ecosystem and relies on HomeKit to manage smart home devices. While Siri’s functionality is commendable, its compatibility with devices is somewhat limited compared to Alexa and Google Assistant. This limitation stems from Siri’s exclusivity to Apple devices. This means that it only integrates with Apple devices, which may pose a drawback for users without Apple products. To maximise Siri’s effectiveness with smart home devices, you’ll need dedicated Apple hardware like HomePods or Apple TV to serve as hubs for automation and remote access.

Playing music

When it comes to playing music or audio, Alexa offers a wide selection of speakers to choose from and seamlessly integrates with Audible for audiobook lovers. However, Google Assistant generally takes the lead in this category. The Assistant stands out for its ability to effortlessly move music and video between different devices using a single command. Plus, its capability to understand and execute two commands in one sentence, means you don’t have to fumble when adjusting volume settings. On the other hand, Alexa’s method for transferring audio can be a bit cumbersome, often requiring you to ‘pause’ in one room and ‘resume’ in another. Additionally, Alexa lacks support for transferring video content. But it does provide an app-based output selection feature similar to Sonos.

Both Alexa and Google Assistant support a range of popular streaming services like Spotify, Apple Music, Netflix, and others. However, there are some gaps in compatibility, notably Alexa’s lack of support for YouTube, YouTube TV, and YouTube Music on Echo devices. Although there’s a workaround for Echo Shows, and the Echo Show 15 allows switching to native Fire TV apps. Alexa is also integrated into other Fire-based devices such as the Fire TV Cube and dedicated TV sets.

On the other hand, while Google-based speakers and displays don’t natively support Amazon Music, you can easily download an app for Google TV or Android.

Switching gears to Siri, it offers similar functionality to Google Assistant for moving audio and video, but relies on the AirPlay framework in place of Google Cast. This means you can effortlessly stream content from your iPhone to compatible devices using Siri commands. While Apple devices were initially the only ones supporting AirPlay, many TV and speaker brands now also support AirPlay and HomeKit. However, Siri still faces compatibility issues, particularly with AirPlay source devices (limited to Apple products) and supported services on HomePods. Although Apple Music was the only option for Siri-controlled music playback for a while, the situation improved in May 2021. Yet, many rival services, including Spotify, are still not fully supported. Nonetheless, you can utilise AirPlay within the Spotify app for streaming to compatible devices.

Answering questions

Google’s search engine is really good at giving answers. That’s why it’s not surprising that Google Assistant is better than other similar tools when it comes to giving detailed and helpful answers.

Researchers tested each smart assistant by asking them 800 questions. The results showed that Google Assistant could understand every question and answer 93% of them correctly. Siri, on the other hand, could only answer 83% of the questions correctly. Alexa did even worse, with only 80% accuracy.

Amazon worked on improving Alexa’s performance, increasing her ability to respond to questions by 18% between 2018 and 2019. In a newer test, Alexa might be catching up to Siri in answering questions, but Google Assistant is still the top performer.

Siri can do other tasks like sending texts, playing music, and managing your calendar pretty well. But when it comes to providing answers, Google Assistant is the best!

Best for voice commands and communication

First up, we’ve got Alexa. It’s pretty handy if you want to keep in touch with other people who also use Alexa. So, if you’ve got one of those Echo smart speakers, you can use the Drop-In feature to have a chat with someone else who has an Echo device.

Moving on to Google Assistant. It’s not as impressive in the communication department compared to Alexa or Siri. Sure, you can make phone calls with it, send texts, and even audio messages. But there’s a catch – you need to use something called IFTTT (If This Then That) to pull that off. However, Google Assistant does come through if you want to make international calls, especially if you’re using a Google Fi or Google Voice account.

Lastly, we’ve got Siri. This one’s pretty versatile when it comes to communication. You can ask Siri to make calls, shoot off text messages, and even send emails to anyone in your contacts. The cool thing? Siri can read your messages and emails aloud, so you don’t have to grab your phone every time. Plus, if things get serious, Siri’s got your back—you can use it to call emergency services.

Device compatibility

Today, Amazon Echo (Alexa) stands tall as one of the top-notch smart speakers you can lay your hands on. In fact, a whopping 70% of smart speakers circulating in the United States are none other than the Echo smart speakers. Why is that, you ask? Well, it’s pretty straightforward. The Echo isn’t just any ordinary smart speaker. It connects with a staggering array of over 140,000 smart devices out there.

As for Google Assistant and Siri, they may come pre-loaded on most shiny new Android and Apple gadgets, respectively. But when it comes to compatibility with smart home gadgets, Alexa takes the lead, ahead of Google’s Nest and Apple’s HomePod speakers.

Google claims about Assistant’s collaboration with over 50,000 smart home gadgets, which is still only a fraction of what Alexa offers. However, Google’s Assistant is rapidly expanding its reach, so it’s wise to keep an eye on its progress.

Now, Siri’s in the game too, but with a limited lineup of smart home gadgets. Apple is still finding its footing in this arena. Apple hasn’t been vocal about the exact number of smart devices Siri integrates with, but their HomeKit system, the backbone of their smart home platform, only showcases around 600 items on their website. So if Siri’s your go-to assistant, you might find yourself a bit restricted when it comes to smart speaker choices.

But if you’re all about having a vast array of devices at your beck and call, Alexa is definitely the way to roll.

Comparing the cost

For Alexa:

Amazon Echo devices come in different price ranges. You can get the Echo Dot (3rd gen) for 23.60GBP, while the top-tier Echo Studio goes for 157.40GBP.

If you’re looking at third-party devices, prices depend on who makes them and the model they offer.

Now, onto Siri:

Siri is available on all Apple devices running iOS 5 or later. This includes iPhones, iPads, iPod touches, and Apple Watches. Prices for these devices vary based on the specific model and how much storage it has.

Moving on to Google Assistant:

Google Home Devices have a range of prices. The Google Nest Mini starts at 38.46GBP, while the high-end Google Home Max goes up to 235.30GBP.

Like with Alexa, third-party devices vary in price depending on the manufacturer and the specific model.

One key thing to remember is that although the devices themselves have different prices, you don’t have to pay extra to use the voice assistants once you own the device. They’re all free to use. Also, each assistant offers a bunch of free services and features. However, you can opt for some premium services, like Amazon Music Unlimited for Alexa or YouTube Premium for Google Assistant, for an extra fee.

Final thought

When it comes to choosing between Alexa, Siri, and Google Assistant, each has its own strengths and weaknesses. If hands-free device control is your priority, Alexa excels. For those accustomed to Apple products and seeking a personable assistant with human-like interaction, Siri stands out. However, if you crave comprehensive answers, knowledge satisfaction, and extensive third-party integrations, Google Assistant is the ultimate choice. Ultimately, selecting the right assistant boils down to your preferences. Regardless of your decision, you can count on having a top-notch assistant always ready to assist.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

X